View the PDF version Google Docs PDF Viewer
CITY OF MUSKEGON PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR MEETING DATE OF MEETING: Thursday, June 13, 2024 at 4 pm PLACE OF MEETING: Commission Chambers, First Floor, Muskegon City Hall AGENDA I. Roll Call II. Approval of minutes from the meetings of May 16, 2024. III. Public Hearings A. Hearing, Case 2024-11: Request to rezone 1903 Marquette Avenue from RM-1, Low-Density Multiple Family Residential, to FBC-NC, Form-Based Code, Neighborhood Core, by the County of Muskegon. B. Hearing Case 2024-12: Request for a special use permit to allow a class B recreational marihuana grow facility at 181 S. Getty Street, by ZAA LLC. IV. New Business V. Old Business A. Approval of bylaws VI. Other VII. Adjourn AMERICAN DISABILITY ACT POLICY FOR ACCESS TO OPEN MEETINGS OF THE CITY OF MUSKEGON AND ANY OF ITS COMMITTEES OR SUBCOMMITTEES To give comment on a live-streamed meeting the city will provide a call-in telephone number to the public to be able to call and give comment. For a public meeting that is not live-streamed, and which a citizen would like to watch and give comment, they must contact the City Clerk’s Office with at least a two-business day notice. The participant will then receive a zoom link which will allow them to watch live and give comment. Contact information is below. For more details, please visit: www.shorelinecity.com The City of Muskegon will provide necessary reasonable auxiliary aids and services, such as signers for the hearing impaired and audio tapes of printed materials being considered at the meeting, to individuals with disabilities who want to attend the meeting with twenty-four (24) hours’ notice to the City of Muskegon. Individuals with disabilities requiring auxiliary aids or services should contact the City of Muskegon by writing or by calling the following: Ann Marie Meisch, MMC. City Clerk. 933 Terrace St. Muskegon, MI 49440. (231)724-6705. clerk@shorelinecity.com 1 Staff Report June 13, 2024 Hearing, Case 2024-11: Request to rezone 1903 Marquette Avenue from RM-1, Low-Density Multiple Family Residential, to FBC-NC, Form-Based Code, Neighborhood Core, by the County of Muskegon. SUMMARY 1. The County of Muskegon purchased Baker College in 2022 and now operates several municipal departments on site, with more relocating there over the next three years. Baker College, Central Dispatch, and West Michigan Medical Consortium currently lease space on site. Other vacant building space is being offered for lease. The County is also considering the sale of additional land on site that it does not need for its operations. 2. The current zoning of RM-1, Low Density Multiple-Family Residential is very restrictive for the types of classroom/office uses that have historically operated on this parcel. A rezoning to Form Based Code, Neighborhood Core would allow these types of uses by right and would also ensure that any building additions would be developed in a walkable, pedestrian friendly pattern. This zoning designation would also allow for varying types of residential development. 3. Please see the zoning ordinance excerpts for RM-1 and FBC, NC districts. 4. Notice was sent to all properties within 300 feet of the focus area. At the time of this writing, staff had not received any comments. 1903 Marquette Ave from the Marquette/Quarterline intersection. 2 Zoning Map Aerial Map 3 STAFF RECOMMENDATION Staff recommends approval of the rezoning. The master plan identifies the Marquette/Quarterline intersection as a potential neighborhood center. New mixed-use options in this area could assist in the redevelopment of this commercial corridor. Master Plan Excerpt DELIBERATION The following proposed motion is offered for consideration: I move that the request to rezone 1903 Marquette Avenue from RM-1, Low-Density Multiple Family Residential, to FBC-NC, Form-Based Code, Neighborhood Core be recommended to the City Commission for approval. 4 Hearing Case 2024-12: Request for a special use permit to allow a class B recreational marihuana grow facility at 181 S. Getty Street, by ZAA LLC. SUMMARY 1. The following marihuana license types are allowed in B-2, B-4, MC, I-1, and I-2 districts with the issuance of a special use permit: Microbusinesses, designated consumption establishments, class B recreational grows, marihuana processing facilities without extraction methods classified as hazardous under the Michigan Building Code, and temporary marihuana events. 2. The property is zoned I-2, General Industrial. The lot measures 36,669 sf and the building measures 15,148 sf. 3. The applicant has requested a special use permit to operate a Class B Marihuana Growing facility, which allows for the production of up to 500 plants. 4. This property was previously used as a marihuana caregiver facility several years ago. 5. Notice was sent to all properties within 300 feet of the focus area. At the time of this writing, staff had not received any comments. Zoning Ordinance Excerpt: Section 2332: Special Land Uses and Planned Unit Developments 5. Standards for Approval of Discretionary Uses Prior to authorization of any Special Land Use, the Planning Commission shall give due regard to the nature of all adjacent uses and structures. It shall determine the consistency with the adjacent use and development. In addition, the Planning Commission shall find that the proposed use or activity would not be offensive, or a nuisance, by reason of increased traffic, noise, vibration, or light. Further, the Planning Commission shall find that adequate water and sewer infrastructure exists or will be constructed to service the Special Land Use or activity. 5 Zoning Map Aerial Map 6 STAFF RECOMMENDATION Staff recommends approval of the special use permit with the condition that the special use permit be revoked if there are repeated odor control violations. DELIBERATION The following proposed motion is offered for consideration: I move that the request for a special use permit to allow a class B recreational marihuana grow facility at 181 S. Getty Street be approved with the following condition: 1. The special use permit be revoked if there are repeated odor control violations. 7 012345683391 5 632 523560 3516362305321342 !"#$%&#'()*"+,#-"*)'(')) 160 .56 2/01 512034567 8965:90;<5971045=0365;9546>5?64;>0=045@30=61:>1A5=045604B1><8965:90B;<597 =209953@46>8?68>04C;3=>09;60=8404C2/5?/2599@030>;99740>A0;4D13041B6>;3456513E0620036/0 313>045=0365;9=546>5?64;3=6/09120>=03456730;<597;3=221;<5971045=0365;9546>5?64C;3= F 1E590F1<0;>G546>5?64H 6423IJJK134305661 3226 33;31 512034567 8965:90;<5971045=0365;9546>5?631E859=53@1>9;3=4/;99E0840=;3=31E859=53@ 4/;99E00>0?60=C46>8?68>;997;960>0=C1>1??8:50=0L?0:6B1>130MN1><1>01B6/0B1991253@4:0?5B50=8404C 83904416/0>2540:>1A5=0=B1>536/54>=53;3?0K HO099>53?5:;94040><5660=536/0130;<597;3=12221;<5971045=0365;9546>5?64256/6/0916 ;>0;C7;>=C;3=B911>;>0;>0P85>0<0364B1>130MN;3=621MQNB;<597=209953@40P8;961;690;466/0 >0P85>0<03641B6/05<<0=5;6097;E86653@>045=0365;9=546>5?6H QHO 8965:90=209953@4;3=>12/18404B1>;3738<E0>1BB;<59504H RHO0??>0=560=B>;60>3567;3=41>1>567/184042/0391?;60=31690446/;3620367MQJNB006B>1<;3716/0> 91653;37>045=0365;9=546>5?6H SHO.0=T.>0;GB;46B;?5956504C83=0>6/0B1991253@?13=565134K ;HO2/01230>1>1:0>;61>1B6/0618>546/1<04/;9995A0B89965<0136/0:>0<5404H EHO146>8?68>;9;==5651341>039;>@0<03644/;99E0<;=061;??1<<1=;606/0618>546/1<0840 ;3=310L60>51>;960>;65134616/046>8?68>04/;99E0<;=02/5?/2599?/;3@06/0>045=0365;9 ;::0;>;3?01B6/046>8?68>0H ?HO.>0;GB;46<;7E040>A0=136/0:>0<5404C1397B1>@804641B6/0B;?59567C;3=3116/0><0;94 4/;99E0:>1A5=0=61@80464H =HO1913@60><>036;91B>11<4B1><1>06/;3B18>6003MSN?1340?865A0=;744/;99E0:0><5660=H 1@8046<;746;7B1><1>06/;362036705@/6MQN35@/6453;37@5A0370;>H 0HO2/0>04/;99E0;<;L5<8<1BB5A0MUN@8046>11<4H1<1>06/;3621MQN;=8964;>0:0><5660=61 46;753;37@8046>11<H BHO5@3;@04/;99?13B1><616/;62/5?/54:0><5660=B1>/1<01??8:;6513E8453044041397H1036;9 1B6/0618>546/1<0B1>4:0?5;9@;6/0>53@448?/;420==53@>0?0:65134;3=:;>65044/;99E0 :>1/5E560=H @HO2/0:>1:0>674/;99<006;9991?;9;3=46;60?1=0>0P85>0<0364>0@;>=53@E0=;3=E>0;GB;46 B;?5956504H UHO111<53@/18404256/;?;:;?5671B316<1>06/;36/>00MRN>11<0>4H 012345683391 5 632 523560 3516362305321342 4!"#$%&'&$&!#( '')&!&"!$'$#*+$$#$%#''#,&!-#!"&$&#!. 2&$''*#'#$"$#/#0&"%#&!-!"-%#(&"&$"&$')#!$# ( +###!")$##-% *2/&!&/'*&'"&!-#!$&$''*$*1%#(*$$&!-/#/$&2#!"%# &"!$&'!#$'$!$&$)3456%$ 7&'"&!-#%-$$!$( 8&((&-$''#,"&!$&#!955( )*''#," /#0&""%#!$:&":!")"&!"*#0$(&!&((;&(!$*)#!36 %##$%#%##$#%*&'"&!-$$8"$( 8&((&-$''#," <=#(#/$&#!#%!#!&!"$&'!$( )*/(&$$"(&&*'#(#/$&#! &!'":*$!#$'&(&$"$#$%#''#,&!-. 0$!"%$$"&#:'#!( )*-&0!$##!'&!$$$&( *= &!"!&''#!:'&(&$"$##!'&!$$$&( ( 1&!-!"$&'#&!- "2$#&!-:'&(&$"$##!$"!$$$&( 2)/&!-#'&'0& %2&!-#%(&#"!&!-#&(&'&!$$&#!:'&(&$"$##!'&!$$$&( - %%&'#$",&$&!$",''&!-%#,&$:#!'$!$:((*#%$'-):',): /)&&!:&$$:!-&!##!$!$:'&(&$"$##!'&!$>%(&')$$&( 0''#(#/$&#!*+$$#$%#''#,&!-. &2*&!/#!#/$&!-$#(#/$&#!''&"&!$",''&!-!"#!') ((*#%$&(("&$%(&')&"&!-#!$/(&( )*(/'#)" &&2*&!''0'#'*&!'&!!"!)#$//#/&$'&!&!-# -&$$&#!;&"*)'#':$$#%"'', &&&#;&/(!$#/#''*"&!#(#/$&#!,&$!#&: 0&*$&#!:-':%(:#"#:#'$&'&!$%!"$$*'$#$!#( '! #%/#!#%%$'#$3!$#%'$&'&!$%!:!#;&/(!$#/# ''*",&$0&'#"&*'&!$%!,&$!)"&##$'0&&#! &0#%%$/(&#%'$$&#!&!$'&!0#'$-#%%$/(& &068/'#&0:%'(( *''&;&"##(*$&*''&;&"''#!')*"&!#(/'&! ,&$$//'&*'%&!"*&'"&!-#" 00$&0&$&&!0#'0&!-1&'!#,'"&!-;&/(!$''#(/'),&$$//'&*'%&!" *&'"&!-#" 012345683391 5 632 523560 3516362305321342 2!"#$$#%#&'($%)!!!#**#&!+*"&'('&"'( #)''$#& ,)''$#&!)#-&!%#!#".#%%!%"!$#''&%!/%)$*-! ')!#&"#%"!$#'"%*'#&! 0**#'-)!+'&"'"/&#$%0!&1!%'%2)''$#&!#** &%.%&%&#*%0%&#*#*%#&!%&*'&!%'&(#%!& '!)#%*-(&"&"/**&1! 02%!#**+&0%%"!$*#-%!1%#&#!1#**/"(%) ''$#&!&"%!1&%.%)&!(!%"&#&' 01"!!#**+2$3%!*"/'#%)#"%#!!)+*"((!30'$#! &'"&#*!%'!%&"%" 02$%)#%-(&'&($%)!!!#**+#(%!"&'((#)*-3#&" ''$#&!#**&0'"/&-(4567$%'&($%&'$#*+*"&1 02%!#**+&!"!%#1%$%'!!&1 02)''$#&!#**&&*%&!('))%'#*'*!(% "*%-()#%#*!#&"(%)$%)!!2%!#**+&'))%'#*'*! #!!'#"/)''$#&3&%$#%2&1()%#&&47+!&!!'#%3 $'2$%'2%!)#**#&&$%)!! 00'!!$'('#**-$%+"4+&*)"7&'*"8 470!%'%%$#%()%'*!3#$$*#&'!#&"%*#%1.$)& 4570!%'%)#&(#'%&1$%'!!/'/*"&%)#**-%.%&"!%#* 9&&1 4:70'))%'#*("!%'%.%&1#*'&! 4;70*)!&!%' 4670*"1&1!%'&'*"&1+&*)"3#%!)3)*%* 4<70# $#%*% 470&#&)#*!$#*%2&&* 4=70*#/&!%' 0#'-*1#**-0'*""+-#&-""%!%'&%%&#&%/&%%!%'&! !#**+$%)" =!%4#%)#**>%$,)! 012345683391 5 632 523560 3516362305321342 05!"#$%&'()*+$$+,!#++ - "2)()"$$.+/+()"0123(4(.'$! .2)*"#$%)"$$."$"+)+'"*)'(1&5663**(+/"%+)(/$"( *"#$% 60##+(%.'$!""##+(%'#'+/"($%#"$+)".+(#4"$(/ /$"(+)".+(#4"$(/ 64236-6430550661 3226 2)*+$$+,!'&")("##+(%.'$!""##+(%'&)"$$.4(/'()4'(,+* #+7887"*((,""44(+"$+*)'1""4$"&*(9'(3.%)$" !4+//+ & "*('.$#:"(!&'.;#+)"44$#".$#++&""%+)(("+ ".$#++ /4+.%) $" !4+//+ - **#"#$#+*4)%#"&&"(#)#&!(&"+(%&"##+' "&("$" "44("(&+(+)(4(+*+ "$4(+<("$"&'("#&#((#1+)()"$+"3+**# "/$"(.''44$%!(#"+*4(+'#,)(/.%)$" ! 4+//+ '4+"44$#"++&+.#+,))"'("#+ ++*!).+(!' "('#'( 7='$!+.'0#$'$%+)+')+**#+*##&($!+'+(#)"(".$+(!">"+&) "#+*,)#)"(#+'#.%/"$&",)#)"(+4$"%!+()"$!/(#)"+( ((!(#+)4(/ 8#)++$"#+$$!++$!)'+*/#)"#"$9'4/0#4'#)"#'+/"($% *+',$$!+(4(+*+ "$+**#4(+)""%'#).'$!)"$$.$+#"+$)" )(%1863**(+/"%+)($+"%("$(# ?0'$+(4"(5"(!@(+'4:+/&4(+)"'#)*"#$%)"$$."$"+)+'"* )'(1&5663**(+/"%+)(/$"(*"#$% 5(+'$%0!+(".$)#+//(#"$'+"$("%#+(+"("$'/"%. "')+(>'(4#"$(/*+()*+$$+,!- "1"$"A+((#".$)//!)+*)!).+()++5/=' B+ 1= 3"$!(#$%,)#+ '/(#$'!- 0 %!("$$%(#+!>("$.',)#)'44$,#+//++ ) 4(/*+(4(+ (!";"#("$"("'#)"-!(+#(&/"& "(%4(+'#&."C!+++(+)(*++&('!&(%!++&"++ +()"(,"( 0 %4(+ "$(#".$)/,)#)4(*+(/(#+)4(/*+( 4(+ (!";"#("$"("&'#)"-)+(4"(&(+4+**(%#$"! )+4&"$+()+4&."'%4"($+(&."(.()+4&(/"C(&"$+(&4)"(/"#&+(" 012345683391 5 632 523560 3516362305321342 !"#!$%"#&'#!&#%# ((!)%(%&!"% !%*+%%)%)%!##%#,)#!! -#% !#!"&+,)#(%#'#!!##%!-'./0(%#! (#1"!1!&%(%&#%#%(%#)!$#-$##"2 23%#-#!#--)#-"#)#%&41%&"!&)%#(%)#%&##(&%))& !$!%&))#+!!&!"%#%"(%#-#!2 '231+%!&#%#%()%'!$-##"&5)("%'!#%"%'%#+$%+%!2 23%#"+60)'()-)1(%#"!)+"%(%#%%')#-##%')!" #%%$*+( !7!+-)+%!$(%#)4)4#+"!#% 1%*+%!"+% 8#!!$7!1)'14)1)# !+!)"+#!#&+!$!#%#"#%7!"!1 )'14)1"'%1--)+%%#+!"!$(%#(%12 )234#!"#!6 23 +"##%#%$(%#"2 232%"'#"#((%#'"+!#5)"&/99*+%-2 230$##"(%#"+)"#!(% #"%#!(% 4% (%#"+)"2 '230+!&%')!$&#%(%#)!$)#!"+)"4!)# (1!)#" +"!$&#%!!%()-)1((%#'"1!!!$4# #!2 '23%:!$))# #""#!#%4"%(%:!$2 '23;#+%#-#(%#!1"1!!!$4# #!2 '23$!+)# (14#-#%-#%%"!8#!!$"%)2 '232!!!$4# #!1#4+#)##'%4# #!1 1(#-)!(("-#%#%#!"-#%#-)###! &#+% #-#(%#!&!"!1#%%%)#!!!""#8&(%#)&!"!)#+%$ %"!)%)%#-%22++$!((%#'-%# )$! 5*+#%4#!%#4# #!-#%)##)!#%#"2 <230))#%1+"!$!"))#%1+)+# %1!)"!##'()5!"% "2 23%##'()5!"% "2 642396506326865 62 !!""'#( !1#4"1!!!$4# #!+!"%(%#)"+%$+"!#- )#!922!!#-!!"!'#( !!1 5#4!1 +( 11"! %)##45"!"+&4)%)# (#)#%&4(%#!$!#!%"!+ 4)4#+"!#)# (#%% #!#+4%"!"4!$2 012345683391 5 632 523560 3516362305321342 642301600516316 62 !"!#$%&'()*+&,-((% .(&%/0&((1(-%$02%3#(334516(##7"%&8(29"#1:9#(:32( (13:%(1$8(&8:3(2(,"2(!(%;< = :>!"!#$%3$?(2:7( "#17&5< :?(!(%.< ;5$%61%@-((%0&@:##9(!(:&"2(1:%2$:1-2$%:7("#(&&:3"#1(&:3)%@(!(:&"2(1-2$! &(%9:3A4 5 :>!"!9"#1761%@;<0:&:8$2%$$-%@(#$%61%@4 1%@%$1(8%@2:%$&2@(1(8%@$-:/#$%0&4$28:23(#0&4&@:##$%9(!$2(%@:%@2((04%!(&#$7(2 %&61%@ *B(7@%#!%&%$2(&$2;-((% B(7@%!(:&"2(!(%3%@(3:&($-:8238:#9"#17)%@(?(2%3:#1&%:3(!(:&"2(1-2$!%@( :?(2:7(-&@(172:1(%$%@(@7@(&%8$%$-%@(2$$-&"2-:3(6@(2(%@(9"#17#(:9"%&%@(-2$ % /:21)(>3(8%:&-$##$6&%$%@(1(3A#($-!:&:212$$-&):1%@(:?(2:7(@(7@%9(%6(((:?(&:1 %@(217($-7:9#()@8):17:!92(#2$$-&0&((7"2(..43-%@(72$"1&$%(%2(#/#(?(#)%@(72:1( &@:##9(1(%(2!(19/:?(2:77%@((#(?:%$$-%@(72$"1-$2(:3@-:3($-%@(9"#170&((7"2( .4 +2$ %(%9:3A& !"! 6>82(&&6:/$202%(2:#%2((%-((% 4$##(3%$2$2 :C$2%2((%.;-((% $2%2((%.-((% 1(:2&(%9:3A-((% (%9:3A-2$!%@($21:2/@7@6:%(2!:2A$26(%#:1;-((%08238:#&%2"3%"2(&$ #/4 .1(&(%9:3A& &%$2/*-((%:1.-((% .&%$2/-((%:1=-((% &%$2/.-((%:15-((% 012345683391 5 632 523560 3516362305321342 !"#!$%0&&#'"(#)*&&!"#)+#!*#(,*+-.&($* $#/($+*)#!($))#(/&($+"(&)($,0 1023#&&($/($%-/#($(/&"(&)($,!.#)$*##&&($$)4#$()&&($ /#5())% 022*"(&)($,*$//#5)+(##($,+#6#&&($)5&/!$"$)#*"(&)($,)0 022*"(&)($,*)'"+(#/##5)/"#"$+(#)#'"(#!$0 022*6#&&($()($)7$#0 )020!($$$!$(,#$).*)7$/#/#.-$#$)##))-(* *4"$.1,(#+)$)/#5())*6$($,)!($(##-(**(/&$# /&/&$0 023($)7$-&$)#-#+#$0 020&&#'"(#)()$)##*&&&$)/),#$&"++#"$&6#&&($( !/&.)+##""##+(#00&+(+./#$+&&#'"(#)+#$*&& &$)/)$))7$*#)#(,*+-.00$5#,!($(!"!,#$&+8+*&& !($($)&$,*#+#$,0 !"#""$% lmnop#o$#qr!"#" cd(Cef&bg&(EhbE(if&bf&(Efa(abjChik&ief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`/*,.-(2*'50(7.04/;A7 a(^.-,3<(0'(7</::(7,-.(7.04/;A7 b(`/*,.-(2*'50/8.7 d(Cef&bg&(EhbE(seCE&ief 012356789 5 5 25 657905 !" #$%%& $%%&B%C#=>?>!@A '()*+,-.//+0)12.30.45)/6*+78)12.30.45)/6*+)9+.59/78):40)12.30.45)/6*+)3;/)7.<+7 12.30.45)/6*+) #=>?>!@A abcde J./9)^,;4/:5+);*/.;4 jkifblfhmcbm ffbgh eih noepgeiqhrbeqrf noepgeiqhpkfhsetb uEHG)7/;,+^,;4/ 1D),EFGH )XHIYD)NQR)P))XHIYD)NEO 3IH)JEKHGL)M)NEO)P)U(M)NQR))3IH)0STHGL)U((M)NEO uEHG)1:3_;46 1D),EFGH )XHIYD)NQR)P))XHIYD)NEO 3IH)JEKHGL)M)NEO)P)U(M)NQR))3IH)0STHGL)U((M)NEO -.y+0x27+ 12.30.45 uEHG)/+,,:_+ _IOKEHEIOQ\)` )XHIYD)NQR)P))XHIYD)NEO 3IH)JEKHGL)M)NEO)P)U(M)NQR))3IH)0STHGL)U((M)NEO /6*+ uEHG)^;,+_;2,/ 1D),EFGH )XHIYD)NQR)P))XHIYD)NEO 3IH)JEKHGL)M)NEO)P)U(M)NQR))3IH)0STHGL)U((M)NEO uEHG)0,.w+x/9,;259 1D),EFGH )XHIYD)NQR)P))XHIYD)NEO 3IH)JEKHGL)M)NEO)P)U(M)NQR))3IH)0STHGL)U((M)NEO uEHG)7/;,+^,;4/ 1D),EFGH U)XHIYD)Z[E\KEOF)\ENEH 3IH)JEKHGL)M)NEO)P)U(M)NQR))3IH)0STHGL)U((M)NEO 9;27+ 12.30.45 12.30.45 -23/.x*3+y -23/.x*3+y 12.30.45 ,+/:.3 12.30.45)/6*+ 12.30.45) ,+/:.3 uEHG)/+,,:_+ _IOKEHEIOQ\` U)XHIYD)Z[E\KEOF)\ENEH 3IH)JEKHGL)M)NEO)P)U(M)NQR))3IH)0STHGL)U((M)NEO /6*+ uEHG)0,.w+x/9,;259 1D),EFGH U)XHIYD)Z[E\KEOF)\ENEH 3IH)JEKHGL)M)NEO)P)U(M)NQR))3IH)0STHGL)U((M)NEO uEHG)7/;,+^,;4/ 1D),EFGH )XHIYD)NQR)P))XHIYD)NEO3IH)JEKHGL)(M)NEO)P)(M)NQR))3IH)0STHGL)U((M)NEO uEHG)/+,,:_+ _IOKEHEIOQ\` )XHIYD)NQR)P))XHIYD)NEO3IH)JEKHGL)(M)NEO)P)(M)NQR))3IH)0STHGL)U((M)NEO 0+/:_9+0) 02*3+y ,;J9;27+ 7-:33) 3:,5+) 3.w+)P)J;,z _;//:5+) ^3+y uEHG)^;,+_;2,/ 1D),EFGH )XHIYD)NQR)P))XHIYD)NEO3IH)JEKHGL)(M)NEO)P)(M)NQR))3IH)0STHGL)U((M)NEO uEHG)0;;,6:,0 1D),EFGH )XHIYD)NQR)P))XHIYD)NEO3IH)JEKHGL)(M)NEO)P)(M)NQR))3IH)0STHGL)U((M)NEO uEHG)7/;,+^,;4/ 1D),EFGH )XHIYD)NQR)P)U)XHIYD)NEO3IH)JEKHGL)M)NEO)P)V(M)NQR))3IH)0STHGL)V(M)NEO 12.30.45 uEHG)0;;,6:,0 1D),EFGH )XHIYD)NQR)P)U)XHIYD)NEO3IH)JEKHGL)M)NEO)P)V(M)NQR))3IH)0STHGL)V(M)NEO uEHG)7/;;* 1D),EFGH )XHIYD)NQR)P)U)XHIYD)NEO3IH)JEKHGL)M)NEO)P)V(M)NQR))3IH)0STHGL)V(M)NEO uEHG)7/;,+^,;4/ 1D),EFGH )XHIYD)Z[E\KEOF)YS][EYSK 3IH)JEKHGL)UVM)NEO)P)'M)NQR))3IH)0STHGL)V(M)NEO uEHG)0;;,6:,0 1D),EFGH )XHIYD)Z[E\KEOF)YS][EYSK 3IH)JEKHGL)UVM)NEO)P)'M)NQR))3IH)0STHGL)V(M)NEO /6*+ uEHG)3.59/J+33 1D),EFGH )XHIYD)Z[E\KEOF)YS][EYSK 3IH)JEKHGL)UVM)NEO)P)'M)NQR))3IH)0STHGL)V(M)NEO uEHG)7/;;* 1D),EFGH )XHIYD)Z[E\KEOF)YS][EYSK 3IH)JEKHGL)UVM)NEO)P)'M)NQR))3IH)0STHGL)V(M)NEO uEHG)^;,+_;2,/ 1D),EFGH )XHIYD)NQR)P))XHIYD)NEO3IH)JEKHGL)WM)NEO)P)U(M)NQR))3IH)0STHGL)U((M)NEO /6*+ 12.30.45)/6*+ 12.30.45)/6*+ uEHG)0;;,6:,0 1D),EFGH )XHIYD)NQR)P))XHIYD)NEO3IH)JEKHGL)WM)NEO)P)U(M)NQR))3IH)0STHGL)U((M)NEO uEHG)7/;;* 1D),EFGH )XHIYD)NQR)P))XHIYD)NEO3IH)JEKHGL)WM)NEO)P)U(M)NQR))3IH)0STHGL)U((M)NEO uEHG)*,;v+_/.45)*;,_9 1D),EFGH )XHIYD)NQR)P))XHIYD)NEO3IH)JEKHGL)WM)NEO)P)U(M)NQR))3IH)0STHGL)U((M)NEO uEHG)7/;;* 1D),EFGH ')XHIYD)NQR)P))XHIYD)NEO3IH)JEKHGL)(M)NEO)P)V(M)NQR))3IH)0STHGL)U((M)NEO uEHG)*,;v+_/.45)*;,_9 1D),EFGH ')XHIYD)NQR)P))XHIYD)NEO3IH)JEKHGL)(M)NEO)P)V(M)NQR))3IH)0STHGL)U((M)NEO uEHG)+45:5+0)*;,_9 1D),EFGH ')XHIYD)NQR)P))XHIYD)NEO3IH)JEKHGL)(M)NEO)P)V(M)NQR))3IH)0STHGL)U((M)NEO uEHG)3.59/J+33 1D),EFGH )XHIYD)Z[E\KEOF)YS][EYSK 3IH)JEKHGL)UVM)NEO)P)'(M)NQR))3IH)0STHGL)U((M)NEO uEHG)7/;;* 1D),EFGH )XHIYD)Z[E\KEOF)YS][EYSK 3IH)JEKHGL)UVM)NEO)P)'(M)NQR))3IH)0STHGL)U((M)NEO uEHG)*,;v+_/.45)*;,_9 1D),EFGH )XHIYD)Z[E\KEOF)YS][EYSK 3IH)JEKHGL)UVM)NEO)P)'(M)NQR))3IH)0STHGL)U((M)NEO uEHG)7/;;* uEHG)*,;v+_/.45)*;,_9 12.30.45)/6*+ /6*+ uEHG)+45:5+0)*;,_9 uEHG)7/;;* uEHG)*,;v+_/.45)*;,_9 uEHG)+45:5+0)*;,_9 _:,,.:5+)9;27+)12.30.45)/6*+ _.w._)12.30.45)/6*+ 1D),EFGH ')XHIYD)NQR)P))XHIYD)NEO3IH)JEKHGL)M)NEO)P)U(M)NQR))3IH)0STHGL)U((M)NEO {|}~~}}~}~}|}}~~} |~|}{~}~}}~}~} 5 25 657905 012356789 5 ! "#$##%& !'()*+$*%$,-"#$# ./0123453670839:0;4<=:>:69 ?ABAC0DE03FGHDCIDJEK0/L0BEC0MGJFNJKO0HJDA0PFIQARAKD0 344289?<93h60/L0123453670839:0;4<=:>:69 <0SCEKD01GJFNTDETUEKA0VID0BCEKD0HDCAADWX Y?AZGJ 0 CAN0MGJFNTDET[EKA0BCER0/0DE0/0BAAD0 = 1 BCER0BCEKD0PCEPACD\0FJKA0 0 ]ANT2HA0IKN0?ADIJF01GJFNJKO09\PAH0JK0D^JH0 ?: Y>J <?0;?h;:?9i0 436: =EKDA]D0<CAI0H^IFF0^I_A0BIQINA0PFIQAN0 5 ID0BCEKD0PCEPACD\0FJKA0VCAZGJCAN0MGJFNTDET FJKA0ID0BCEKD0PCEPACD\0FJKAW0 108JNA01GJFNTDETUEKA0VID0HJNA0HDCAADWX Y?AZGJ 0 CAN0MGJFNTDET[EKA0BCER0/0DE0/0BAAD0 BCER0HJNA0PCEPACD\0FJKA0 835:0;?h;:?9i0436: Y>J 0 ]ANT2HA0IKN0?ADIJF01GJFNJKO09\PAH0JK0D^JH0 123453670 : =EKDA]D0<CAI0H^IFF0^I_A0BIQINA0PFIQAN0 Shh9;?369 ID0HJNA0PCEPACD\0FJKA0VCAZGJCAN0MGJFNTDETFJKA0 835:089?::9 835:0;?h;:?9i0436: ID0HJNA0PCEPACD\0FJKAW0 =08JNA08ADMIQ`0VID0KEKTHDCAAD0FEQIDJEKHWX Ya 00BAAD0BCER0HJNA0PCEPACD\0FJKA S?h690;?h;:?9i0 50?AIC08ADMIQ`X 436: Yb 0/0BAAD0BCER0CAIC0PCEPACD\0FJKA S?h69089?::9 :0:KQCEIQ^RAKDHX01IFQEKJAHc0IdKJKOHc0QIKEPJAHc0 AI_AHc0QECKJQAHc0IKN0MI\0dJKNEdHc0RI\0PCEeAQD0 < JKDE0CAZGJCAN0HADMIQ`Hc0MA\EKN0CAZGJCAN0MGJFNT DET[EKAHc0EC0JKDE0D^A0PGMFJQ0CJO^DTEBTdI\0IH0 JKNJQIDAN0JK08AQDJEK0//a/ /0;<?@3670;4<=:>:69 ?ABAC0DE03FGHDCIDJEK0/f0BEC0EKTHJDA0PIC`JKO0PFIQARAKD0 344289?<93h60/f0;<?@3670;4<=:>:69 <0SCEKD08ADMIQ`X Y.0/0BAAD0RJKJRGR0BCER0BCEKD0PCEPACD\0FJKA0 = 5 108JNA08ADMIQ`0VBCER0HJNA0HDCAADWX Y00BAAD0RJKJRGR0BCER0HJNA0PCEPACD\0FJKA ?:<?0;?h;:?9i0 436: =08JNA08ADMIQ`0VBCER0KEKTHDCAAD0FEQIDJEKHWX : Y00BAAD0BCER0HJNA0PCEPACD\0FJKA S 50?AIC08ADMIQ`X h6T839:0;<?@3670 Y00BAAD0BCER0CAIC0PCEPACD\0FJKA0ID0KEKTHDCAAD0 ;j<9:?>399:50360 FEQIDJEKH =j:50<?:< 1 Y00BAAD0BCER0CAIC0PCEPACD\0FJKA0ID0HDCAAD0 FEQIDJEKH 835:0;?h;:?9i0436: :0;IC`JKO0FEQIDAN0ID0HJNA0EC0CAIC0HDCAAD0FEQIDJEKH0 : 7 H^IFF0MA0HQCAAKAN0BCER0D^A0HDCAAD0IH0CAZGJCAN0M\0 8AQDJEK0//Lb.0 835:0;?h;:?9i0 835:089?::9 S0;IC`JKO0g0HAC_JQA0ICAIH0H^IFF0KED0MA0IQQAHHAN0 < 436: BCER0BCEKD0HDCAADHc0GKFAHH0IK0IFFA\0EC0HJNA0HDCAAD0 S?h690;?h;:?9i0 JH0KED0I_IJFIMFA0BEC0NCJ_AdI\0PFIQARAKD0 436: >I]JRGR0dJND^0EB0NCJ_AdI\0JH0/0BAAD 705CJ_AdI\0IQQAHH0FEQIDJEKX S S?h69089?::9 Y=EC 0 KAC0FEDX0./0BAAD0RJKJRGR0BCER0HDCAAD0 QECKAC Y30KDACJEC0FEDX0dJD^JK00BAAD0EB0HJNA0PCEPACD\0 FJKAc0d^AK0IFFA\0JH0KED0I_IJFIMFA 012356789 5 5 25 657905 !" #$%%& $%%&'%(#)*+*!,- ./012345662708929 #)*+*!,-:;#!" 726FEH270HI8920 EF335FG20HI8920 94FKK048K65R1K2S0 KF3G2048K65R1K2S EI66FG20326F5K0 J85K75LG06M12 J85K75LG06M12 J85K75LG06M12 J85K75LG06M12 J85K75LG06M12 J85K75LG06M12 J85K75LG06M12 J85K75LG06M12 J85K75LG06M12 J85K75LG06M12 J85K75LG06M12 J85K75LG06M12 K5N20P0OI3Q0 3IOHI892 45S2708920 <=>?@A?BCD> 781K2S0 E5N5E0 326F5K TK2S FuuV\\{W0~Yw[Yx\0vx[0~\V\ 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 FX~\VXVxZ0vx[0WVuWVvZY{x0zvuYwYZ 1 1 1 F~Z{0\VW}YuV0\ZvZY{x 9 9 9 9 Jvx 1 1 1 J~\YxV\\0\u{{wPtWY}vZV0{W0t~wYu0\u{{wPYVW0V[ 1 E~Wu 1 Ew~0w{[V0vww 1 GvwwVWPX~\V~X 1 1 1 H{ZVwPX{ZVw 1 5x[{{W0ZVvZVWPwY}V0X~\Yu0u{xuVWZ0vww0 1 1 KYZ0Xvx~zvuZ~WYx 9 1 1 4vuYxV0\{t 9 1 1 4YuW{0WV VW0[Y\ZYwVW0YxVW0~x[VW0//0vWWVw\ 1 1 1 1 4YuW{0WV VW0[Y\ZYwVW0YxVW0{}VW0//0vWWVw\ 1 1 1 4~wZYRzvXYw0 1 1 1 1 qa 1 1 1 1 1 I~Z[{{W0WVuWVvZY{x 1 I~Z[{{W0ZVvZVW 1vWYx0\ZW~uZ~WV 9 1VW\{xvw0\VW}YuV 1 1 1 1 1 3vYwv0ZVWXYxvw 1 3V\VvWu0vx[0[V}Vw{tXVxZ 1 1 3V\Zv~WvxZ0u{uZvYw0w{~xV0WV t~ 1 1 1 1 3VZvYw 1 1 1 1 1 9YttYx0t{WZ0WVwvZV[0vuZY}YZ 1 10U01VWXYZZV[08\V ]^_`_]abcdeeaf_gha_ij_kiibh_eli_mjf_mnioa ]p_`_]abcdeeaf_gha_ij_qbhe_kiib_ijrs 90U09tVuYvw0Kvx[08\V0yWVzVW0Z{09VuZY{x0///| FuZY}V0~\V\0tVW0ZV0E{xZVZ0FWVv04vt0y///|0Yxuw~[V0WVZvYw0WV\Zv~WvxZPu{uZvYw0w{~xVPWV t~0tVW\{xvw0\VW}YuV0vx[0XYuW{0WV VWP[Y\ZYwVWP YxVW Jwvx0uVww0U08\V0x{Z0tVWXYZZV[0Yx0ZY\0E{xZVZ0FWVv 9v[V[0vWVv\0WVtWV\VxZ0J~Yw[Yx06tV\0ZvZ0vWV0x{Z0tVWXYZZV[0Yx0ZY\0E{xZVZ0FWVv0 5 25 657905 012356789 5 #$%%& !" $%%&'%(#)*+*!,- ./0123456627089290:;<=>?=@ABC #)*+*!,-#!" 726ONQ270QR8920 NO335OP20QR8920 94OTT048T65[1T2\0 TO3P2048T65[1T2\ NR66OP20326O5T0 S85T75UP06V12 S85T75UP06V12 S85T75UP06V12 S85T75UP06V12 S85T75UP06V12 S85T75UP06V12 S85T75UP06V12 S85T75UP06V12 S85T75UP06V12 S85T75UP06V12 S85T75UP06V12 S85T75UP06V12 T5W20Y0XR3Z0 3RXQR892 45\2708920 DEFGHIGJKLF 781T2\0 N5W5N0 326O5T ]T2\ 9~z_ABYN<[<y0~<@a?= 1M 1M 1 1 9?={A[|z`?{0_Aa?BA=>?z{0 1M 1 1 6z?Y{?`<0aA_}?;A 1 1 1 1 6<[|z`?{0_Aa?BA=>?z{0 8aAa0a?`?{z_0><0yA_`?>>AB0@aAa 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 8aAa0a?`?{z_0><0ayA;?z{0@aAa 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 WA>A_?=z_0z=B0A==A{ 1 Xz_A~<@a?= 1 1 X?=B0>@_?=A 1 10^01A_`?>>AB08aA bcdedbfghijjfkdlmfdnodpnngmdjqndrokdrsntf budedbfghijjfkdlmfdnodvgmjdpnngdnowx 90^09yA;?z{0Tz=B08aA0:_A|A_0><09A;>?<=0///C O;>?}A0@aAa0yA_0>~A0N<=>A>0O_Az04zy0:///C0?=;{@BA0_A>z?{0_Aa>z@_z=>Y;<;>z?{0{<@=AY_Ay@0yA_a<=z{0aA_}?;A0z=B0̀?;_<0_AA_YB?a>?{A_Y?=A_ S{z=0;A{{0^08aA0=<>0yA_`?>>AB0?=0>~?a0N<=>A>0O_Az 9~zBAB0z_Aza0_Ay_AaA=>0S@?{B?=06yAa0>~z>0z_A0=<>0yA_`?>>AB0?=0>~?a0N<=>A>0O_Az0 012356789 5 5 25 657905 CITY OF MUSKEGON PLANNING COMMISSION BYLAWS OFFICERS The offices to be filled by the Planning Commission are: 1. Chairperson 2. Vice-Chairperson 3. Representative to the Zoning Board of Appeals (appointed by the mayor) ELECTION OF OFFICERS Officers shall be elected February of each year. Officers shall serve for a one (1) year term. DUTIES A Chairperson shall preside at all meetings and shall conduct all meetings in accordance with the rules provided herein. The vice-chairperson shall act in the capacity of the chairperson in the absence of the chairperson and shall succeed to the office of chairperson in the event of a vacancy in that office. REGULAR MEETINGS The Planning Commission shall schedule at least twelve (12) regular meetings per year. All regular meetings, special meetings, and/or hearings shall be conducted in compliance with the Open Meetings Act P.A. 267 of 1976, the Planning Enabling Act P.A. 33 of 2008, and the Planning Enabling Act P.A. 110 of 2006. All meetings shall be publicly posted at least 84 hours in advance of the meeting in a place visible to the public. The schedule of regular meetings will be posted for the public within ten (10) days of the first meeting of the calendar/fiscal year. All meetings shall begin at 4:00 p.m. At any time during the meeting, any member of the board may make a motion to adjourn. SPECIAL MEETINGS A special meeting may be called by the Chairperson or staff after an applicant request a meeting and pays the associated fees. Two members of the Planning Commission may 1 also call a meeting upon written request to the Planning Department. The business which the Planning Commission may perform shall be conducted at a public meeting of the Planning Commission held in compliance with the Open Meetings Act. Public Notice of the time, date, and place of the special meeting shall be given in a manner as required by the Opening Meetings Act, and the Planning Department shall send written notice of a special meeting to commission members not less than 48 hours in advance of the meeting. QUORUM OF THE COMMISSION Five (5) members of the total nine (9) members serving constitutes a quorum for the transaction of business. Whenever a quorum is not present, those present shall adjourn the meeting or hearing to another date. The members of the Commission may discuss matters of interest, but can take no action until the next regular or special meeting. All public hearings without a quorum shall be scheduled for the next regular or special meeting and no additional public notice is required, other than the 18-hour notice dictated by the Open Meetings Act, provided the date, time, and place is announced at the meeting. All motions shall be passed with at least a majority of the seated board members. MOTIONS Motions may be restated by the secretary before a vote is taken. The identities of the maker and supporter of the motions shall be recorded. VOTING All votes shall be made by "yes" or "no" and recorded in the minutes in a manner which ascertains how each member voted. All members are expected to exercise their obligation to vote upon a question unless a conflict of interest is present. The order of the roll call vote shall be varied from meeting to meeting and from one vote to the next in a random manner, but the Chairperson shall vote last. ABSTENTION FOR A VOTE A Commission member shall request abstention from a vote if the member might gain personal and/or financial benefits or if direct involvement exists which prevents objectivity. The abstaining member shall state so at the time the item is addressed on the agenda and shall not participate in the discussion as a member of the commission. A Commission member may request to abstain from voting with explanation. 2 GOVERNING PROCEDURE The Michigan Statutes, Planning Commission Bylaws and the Robert's Rules of Order Revised, in that order, shall govern the order of business before the Planning Commission. Robert's Rules shall not apply when they conflict with federal law, Michigan Statutes or they deny a member his/her Constitutional rights. COMMUNICATIONS WITH CITIZENS Contact with Commissioners by citizens falls into two categories: The first category would be contacts of general information seeking (i.e.; meeting dates, composition of commission, procedure to appear before, location of meeting site, or others that merely describe the system.) These may be shared or noted in the minutes at the discretion of the individual commissioner. The second category consists of significant communications, written or verbal, that address Planning Commission business and shall be shared and noted in the minutes (i.e., requests concerning possible change in land use, possible zoning changes, developers inquiries). Ex-parte contact shall be avoided by Commissioners, if possible. Persons wishing to discuss issues with Commissioners should address concerns either in writing to the Planning Commission as a whole or at a Planning Commission meeting. Complaints should be referred to the appropriate City Official. CITIZEN PARTICIPATION Any persons who wishes to speak on an item included on the printed meeting agenda may do so when they are recognized by the Chair, at which time they will be required to step forward to a microphone and requested to state their name and address, or provide it to staff on a piece of paper, and then be allowed three (3) minutes maximum to address the Commission. Citizens may also speak on an item by way of telephone. The telephone number will be broadcast during the filming of the meeting. DISORDERLY CONDUCT AT MEETINGS Persons addressing the Commission shall make responsible comments and shall refrain from making personal, impertinent, slanderous or profane remarks. The Chairperson may call to order any person who is being disorderly by speaking longer than the allotted time; or by speaking vulgarities. Such persons shall thereupon be seated until the Chair shall have determined whether the person is in order. If the person shall continue to be disorderly and disrupt the meeting, the chair may order the Police Department to remove the person from the meeting. 3 ATTENDANCE Members shall follow the attendance policy set forth by the City Commission for appointed Boards and Commissions: The Chairperson of each board, commission, or committee shall be responsible to see that attendance is recorded at each meeting. When deemed appropriate by the Chairperson, a letter will be sent to any member whose attendance is not satisfactory. The letter shall ask if the member is interested in continued appointment. On a yearly basis, staff shall submit a report to the City Clerk showing member attendance and indicating correspondence notices sent to members. At any time the Chairperson deems it appropriate to do so, that Chairperson may recommend replacement of a member for reasons related to the member’s attendance. AMENDMENTS These rules may be amended by the Planning Commission by a concurring vote, during any regular meeting, provided that all members have received an advanced copy of the proposed amendments at least three (3) days prior to the meeting at which such amendments are to be considered. THESE BYLAWS AND RULES OF PROCEDURES ARE ADOPTED THIS 11TH DAY OF APRIL, 2024. City of Muskegon Planning Commission. Chairperson Vice-Chairperson 4
Sign up for City of Muskegon Emails